Is Your Car Worth Fixing?

June 25, 2024


Is Your Car Worth Fixing? | Evaluating Maintenance vs. Buying New

Is it more cost-effective to maintain your current vehicle or to buy a new or used one? Let’s dive into the numbers and help you make an informed decision. Check out our cost-to-own video where we show you how you can save money!


The Cost of Maintaining Your Current Vehicle

First, let's look at the maintenance costs for your existing vehicle over 75,000 miles. Here’s a breakdown of essential services and their costs:


- Fluids, Filters, Belts, Hoses
- Battery
- Shocks and Struts
- Alignment and Tire Rotation
- Spark Plugs


These items combined add up to about $16,337. Adding repairs for wearable items like brakes and tires, the total comes to around $22,337 over 75,000 miles, which averages to about 30 cents per mile.


Comparing with New or Used Vehicles

To get a fair comparison, let’s use Edmunds' cost-to-own calculator for a 2024 Honda Accord:


- True Cost to Own: $44,600 over five years (15,000 miles/year)
- Purchase Price: $31,000


Subtracting the cost of fuel (which varies), the cost per mile is approximately 84 cents.


For a used 2020 Honda Accord:

- True Cost to Own: $44,600
- Purchase Price: $23,000


After adjustments, this comes to about 74 cents per mile.


What Do These Numbers Mean?

When comparing the costs:


- Maintaining Your Current Vehicle: 30 cents per mile
- Buying a New 2024 Honda Accord: 84 cents per mile
- Buying a Used 2020 Honda Accord: 74 cents per mile


Maintaining your current vehicle is significantly cheaper per mile. Investing in regular maintenance can extend the life of your car and save you money in the long run. 


Wayside Garage's Maintenance Plan

At Wayside Garage, we recommend regular maintenance to keep your car in top shape. We are happy to share our maintenance plan with you and set up a personalized plan to match your car care budget. Following our schedule ensures your vehicle remains reliable and safe for many years and miles!

Based on the cost analysis, maintaining your current vehicle is the most financially responsible choice. It not only saves you money but also maximizes the lifespan of your investment. If you have any questions or need assistance, feel free to reach out to us at Wayside Garage. We’re here to help!



Wayside Garage technician checking a tire before a Thanksgiving road trip in Seaside, CA
By Stacey Diaz • November 9, 2026
Driving out of Seaside for Thanksgiving? Here's what to check on your tires, brakes, battery, wipers, and oil before you hit the road.
By Wayside Garage • November 5, 2026
Get expert transmission repair and service at Wayside Garage in Seaside, CA. Improve your car's performance today. Schedule an online appointment now!
Wiper blade clearing a wet windshield before winter rain in Seaside, CA
By Stacey Diaz • November 2, 2026
NOAA says a strong El Niño is likely this winter. Here's how to get your wipers, tires, brakes, battery, and lights ready in Seaside, CA.
By Wayside Garage • October 8, 2026
Ensure optimal vehicle performance with expert wheel alignment and tire balancing at Wayside Garage in Seaside, CA. Visit us today for precision and care!
brake repair seaside ca, monterey peninsula brake service, free brake pads seaside, coastal brake ma
By Stacey Diaz • October 5, 2026
Get free brake pads this October at Wayside Garage in Seaside, CA. We donate 10% of brake repairs directly to Cleveland Clinic breast cancer vaccine research.
By Stacey Diaz • September 30, 2026
Check engine light on? Learn the difference between steady vs flashing lights, why a free code scan isn't a fix, and how Wayside Garage in Seaside diagnoses it.
Mechanic installing a new brake rotor during an inspection at Wayside Garage Seaside CA
By Stacey Diaz • September 15, 2026
Learn why coastal fog, short trips, and hybrid regen cause sticking brake calipers, and why precision fluid testing keeps you safe in Seaside, CA.
By Wayside Garage • September 10, 2026
Discover expert suspension repair services at Wayside Garage in Seaside, CA. Ensure your car's smooth handling and ride comfort. Visit us today!
Automotive technician in protective gloves pouring fresh motor oil into an engine during a preventat
By Stacey Diaz • September 8, 2026
Discover why manufacturer 10K-mile oil intervals accelerate engine wear and how 4K-mile synthetic services help your car last past 300,000 miles in Seaside, CA.
Wayside Garage technician Jose holding degraded engine coolant with heavy calcium buildup and sedime
By Stacey Diaz • September 2, 2026
See what degraded coolant really looks like and how regular cooling system flushes prevent clogged heater cores and costly repairs in Seaside, CA.
More Posts